DRS – Who ought to be India’s subsequent Check captain after Rohit Sharma’s retirement?

India have a number of key choices to make earlier than finalising their squad for the upcoming five-match Check collection in opposition to England. On Might 7, Rohit Sharma introduced his retirement from Check cricket, bringing an finish to a profession within the longest format that spanned over 11 years – from 2013 to 2025.

Rohit’s departure leaves a management void, and India should appoint a brand new captain as they start their marketing campaign within the 2023-25 World Check Championship cycle. Jasprit Bumrah, who led the workforce within the Perth and Sydney Exams in the course of the 2024-25 Border-Gavaskar Trophy, was a robust candidate to take over.

Nevertheless, Bumrah has withdrawn from the captaincy race because of workload administration, as he is probably not out there for all 5 Exams in England. This opens the door for Shubman Gill and Rishabh Pant, who are actually the frontrunners for the position.

Gill has expertise of main India in 5 T20Is and has captained the Gujarat Titans (GT) because the 2024 IPL season. Pant, however, captained India in 5 T20Is in 2022 and has additionally led each the Delhi Capitals (DC) and the Lucknow Tremendous Giants (LSG) within the IPL.

In our newest instalment of the Choice Evaluation System, India As we speak’s sports activities journalists give their tackle the difficulty. Learn on.

Nikhil Naz: Ideally, Jasprit Bumrah can be my first alternative. However since there are doubts over his participation on a constant foundation within the red-ball format owing to workload administration; Rishabh Pant then, for me, can be the best candidate to take over the mantle from Rohit Sharma. Regardless of his meagre returns with the bat within the white-ball format within the latest previous, Rishabh nonetheless stays a sure-shot starter in India’s crimson ball format. A confirmed match winner in exams, coupled along with his astute captaincy in the course of the IPL, makes him the proper candidate for the management position. Possibly Bumrah may very well be vice-captain and the proper sounding board for Rishabh as he settles into his new job.

Akshay Ramesh: Why are we hyping up Shubman Gill proper now? Is he even a certainty within the enjoying XI at this level? The final time he scored a fifty in SENA international locations or the West Indies was again in 2021, in the course of the well-known win on the Gabba.

Why add further strain on a younger batter who remains to be struggling to cement his place within the Check aspect?

If I have been a selector, I’d appoint Jasprit Bumrah as captain and identify a robust vice-captain who can step in when Bumrah is unavailable.

And if Bumrah himself isn’t eager on taking on the position, why not hand it to Rishabh Pant? The wicketkeeper-batter has arguably been India’s greatest red-ball performer throughout all circumstances. Again Pant for 2 years – captaincy and duty would possibly simply convey out the easiest in him.

Saurabh Kumar: If India want a Check captain, who higher than Jasprit Bumrah? He’s a nationwide treasure and has already led in two Exams, together with one in Australia. If Pat Cummins can captain Australia in each Exams and ODIs regardless of his historical past of again stress fractures, why cannot Bumrah tackle the management position for India?

Nevertheless, if Bumrah is just not thought-about because of his health issues, India ought to severely take into account rewarding Rishabh Pant with the captaincy. Pant could also be enduring a tough patch within the IPL, however let’s not neglect that he’s one among India’s best Check batters in abroad circumstances. Whereas Shubman Gill is but to show his mettle overseas, Pant averages over 42 in Exams and has scored centuries in Australia, England, and South Africa, together with seven scores within the 90s.

Siddharth Viswanathan: Once you take a look at India, there has all the time been an inclination to nominate batters as skippers. That’s the reason my alternative is Shubman Gill. The pattern modified with MS Dhoni for six years and Anil Kumble for a quick interval. However, a correct batter has all the time been on the helm.

When one appears to be like on the present choices, India are gazing an influence void. There’s a insecurity in Shubman Gill’s batting exterior Asia. Rishabh Pant’s indiscipline and type doesn’t make him a contender. Inconsistency plagues KL Rahul whereas there are questions over Jasprit Bumrah’s health. However trying on the points the opposite contenders face, Shubman Gill is the least of the concerns. Which is why India’s new Check period ought to start below Shubman.

Sabyasachi Chowdhury: Jasprit Bumrah may have been one of many choices given the cricketing mind he has. However India want a captain who’s not injury-prone and who can play persistently with out having to take a seat out a lot. Rishabh Pant ought to be the frontrunner since he has been a dependable sufficient determine in Check cricket, though he has struggled along with his sport in limited-overs cricket. Earlier, Mohammad Kaif had additionally backed Pant as Rohit’s successor and rightly so. If Pant can perceive higher the distinction between being fearless and reckless, he has the potential to grow to be an excellent Check captain.

Siddarth Gulati: Ideally, Jasprit Bumrah. However with issues over Bumrah’s workload, India would wish a captain who’s a confirmed starter within the XI. That is the place Rishabh Pant dives into the dialogue. That mentioned, Pant might be my choose as the following India Check captain. Regardless of a mean BGT, Pant has been one among India’s greatest batters within the format up to now 5 years. Plus, his wicket-keeping is equally efficient. As a tactician, Pant has been fairly astute in no matter alternatives he has gotten to guide within the IPL.

Shubman Gill arguably has a sword hanging over his Check place. However Pant would not. And that is the place Pant would provide extra assuredness.

Anurag Jha: At current, nobody within the Indian workforce seems really match to take over the Check captaincy. Rishabh Pant’s management and batting type in IPL 2025 haven’t lived as much as expectations. Furthermore, he was inconsistent even in the course of the tour of Australia. One other contender, Shubman Gill, has had a relatively common run in Check cricket.

As for Jasprit Bumrah, appointing him captain can be a dangerous transfer, contemplating his workload administration—he may not even be out there for all matches.

On this situation, why should not the BCCI attempt to persuade Virat Kohli to return for the England tour, regardless that he lately introduced his retirement from Check cricket? If Sunil Chhetri will be persuaded by the Indian soccer workforce’s coach to return out of retirement, absolutely Kohli will be approached too.

Proper now, the Indian Check workforce wants Virat Kohli. A comeback from King Kohli can be a exceptional step ahead.

Harshit: Having a number of choices when deciding a captain is usually a great signal because it tells you that there are gamers who’re ready in line to be given added duty. However in India’s case proper now, it could not essentially be a boon as there are some query marks over every candidate. Nevertheless, for my part, the one going through the least variety of questions and is assured a begin for the foreseeable future is Rishabh Pant. Gill was dropped in Australia, KL Rahul within the collection earlier than that and Bumrah isn’t a certain shot starter in all video games. Pant will be erratic however he affords dynamism. He’s not the only option however his file abroad compels you to strive him out.

Tune In