INDI Bloc Allies In Karnataka, Tamil Nadu Divided On Kamal Haasan’s Kannada Comment
Final Up to date:
Kamal Haasan’s declare that Kannada originated from Tamil sparked political reactions. Karnataka leaders condemned it, demanding an apology, whereas Tamil Nadu’s DMK supported him.
Kamal Haasan additionally emphasises his respect for Kannada language and tradition.
The neighbouring states of Karnataka and Tamil Nadu, which have been combating for many years over the Cauvery water, are actually at odds over a contemporary problem: language. Actor Kamal Haasan’s current comment that Kannada was born out of Tamil has elicited a wave of political reactions, revealing contrasting positions throughout the INDI bloc.
In Karnataka, Congress leaders have strongly condemned Haasan’s assertion and demanded his apology. In the meantime, in Tamil Nadu, the ruling DMK has backed Haasan, sustaining that there’s nothing objectionable in his remark.
Whereas there is no such thing as a direct problem between the 2 state governments, the divergent responses underscore the linguistic sensitivities within the area — even inside politically allied events.
The controversy surfaced forward of the discharge of Haasan’s movie “Thug Life”. The film won’t be launched in Karnataka for now because the actor has refused to apologise for his comment.
Tracing Kannada’s Roots: Why Kamal Haasan’s ‘Born From Tamil’ Declare Has Sparked A Firestorm
What Karnataka Leaders Mentioned
Amid the controversy, Karnataka Chief Minister Siddaramaiah referred to the actor as “poor Kamal Haasan” and mentioned he’s unaware of Kannada’s long-standing historical past.
Deputy CM DK Shivakumar mentioned each states are “buddies and never enemies.” “Let’s not make this a political problem. We’re all neighbours. All of us must work collectively and stay collectively. Our water goes to Tamil Nadu, and the individuals of Tamil Nadu come right here. We’re not enemies, we’re all buddies…I don’t need to touch upon it as a result of I don’t know the historical past of that problem,” he added.
Nevertheless, Karnataka Minister Shivaraj Tangadagi made it clear that actor Haasan’s movies can be “banned” within the state, as determined by the Karnataka Movie Chamber of Commerce (KFCC) if he doesn’t apologise for his remarks.
Karnataka Minister Eshwara Khandre additionally condemned the assertion of Kamal Haasan.
Karnataka minister Santosh Lad additionally echoed the same sentiment and mentioned, “No matter his opinion is, he can say. We have now excessive regard for our land and language. I’ve not gone via his assertion, but when his assertion damages our sentiments in the direction of language, I condemn it.”
DMK Leaders Again Kamal Haasan
Tamil Nadu Minister for Municipal Administration, City and Water Provide Ok. N. Nehru has backed Haasan, saying there’s “nothing improper” in what the actor mentioned.
“Telugu Malayalam languages originated from Tamil, there’s nothing improper with what he mentioned,” he added.
DMK Spokesperson TKS Elangovan mentioned Haasan didn’t insult Kannada and blamed the BJP for dividing the individuals.
“When the BJP enters into any problem, they’ll speak all nonsense…Kamal Haasan might need learn and quoted some historic information. It’s not his discovering. This doesn’t imply that he’s insulting Kannada…It’s not Kamal Haasan’s view…BJP’s function is to create bother amongst individuals. They need to divide individuals. BJP is just not a celebration for the sake of the individuals. No one is towards Kannada. Many individuals reside in Tamil Nadu who communicate Kannada, and we respect them,” he mentioned.
It’s value noting that Haasan will quickly enter Rajya Sabha with the assistance of ally DMK.
The place Does BJP Stand On Kamal Haasan Row?
The BJP, which is in opposition in each states, has tried to tread fastidiously on the difficulty. Whereas its leaders have slammed Haasan, they shunned commenting a lot on the Tamil-Kannada row, saying all languages belong to India.
Tamil Nadu BJP President Nainar Nagenthiran mentioned, “If we analysis whether or not Kannada originated from the Tamil language, there can be variations of opinion, however in the end, all languages are ours.”
Tamil Nadu BJP vice chairman Narayanan Thirupathy mentioned Haasan shouldn’t belittle any language to reward your language. “From the place did Kamal Haasan study that Kannada is born from Tamil?.. A celeb like him must be extra accountable due to his societal stature. He ought to inform the place he discovered all this from. Is there any doc that claims this?… He cannot attempt to escape from what he mentioned. Kamal Haasan owes a proof,” he mentioned.
BJP chief Tamilisai Soundararajan mentioned, “Everytime you specific the richness of your individual language, you must also take into consideration different languages… Why didn’t Kamal Hasan point out this beforehand when he was appearing in Kannada, Telugu and Hindi motion pictures? Why now he needs to disrupt the brotherhood of different states?”
Karnataka BJP chief Vijayendra Yediyurappa mentioned Haasan has disrespected Kannada and asserted it’s the peak of conceitedness and conceitedness of an actor who has acted in lots of Indian languages, together with Kannada.
“One ought to love one’s mom tongue, however displaying disrespect in its identify is uncultured behaviour. Particularly artists ought to have the tradition of respecting each language,” he mentioned.
Union Minister of State Shobha Karandlaje, a Lok Sabha MP from Banglore North, condemned Haasan’s assertion and alleged that the actor needs to create an issue between states and their languages.
What Kamal Haasan Mentioned
Throughout a promotional occasion for “Thug Life” final week, Kamal Haasan claimed that “Kannada was born out of Tamil”, sparking widespread outrage amongst pro-Kannada teams and cultural organisations.
Haasan made these remarks whereas addressing Sandalwood star Shiva Rajkumar, who was current on the occasion.
“You might be my household that’s residing in Karnataka, and therefore, you got here all the way in which right here. Once I began the speech, I mentioned that my life and my household are Tamil. Your language was born out of Tamil, and therefore you might be a part of it,” mentioned Kamal Haasan to Shiva Rajkumar.
Later, Haasan defended his comment, saying that he mentioned it out of affection and that a number of historians have taught him the historical past of languages. “I didn’t imply something. Tamil Nadu is a state the place a Menon has been our Chief Minister, the place a Reddy has been our Chief Minister, a Tamil has been our CM, and a Kannadiga Iyengar has been our CM… Politicians usually are not certified to speak about language. They don’t have the {qualifications} to speak about it, together with me. Allow us to go away all these very in-depth discussions to historians, archaeologists and language specialists,” he mentioned.
(With inputs from ANI, PTI)
Saurabh Verma covers normal, nationwide and worldwide day-to-day information for News18.com as a Senior Sub-editor. He keenly observes politics. You possibly can comply with him on Twitter –twitter.com/saurabhkverma19
Saurabh Verma covers normal, nationwide and worldwide day-to-day information for News18.com as a Senior Sub-editor. He keenly observes politics. You possibly can comply with him on Twitter –twitter.com/saurabhkverma19
- First Revealed:
