PIP advantages: ‘Worrying’ variety of teenagers lose funds at age 16

Youngsters with incurable situations are amongst lots of every week being stripped of incapacity advantages after their sixteenth birthdays.

Almost a 3rd of those that acquired Incapacity Dwelling Allowance (DLA) in childhood had claims for Private Independence Fee (PIP) rejected when attempting to maneuver to the grownup profit, BBC evaluation has discovered.

Incapacity charity Scope stated a “complicated, adversarial and troublesome to navigate” system contributed to the rejections.

With widespread advantages reform proposals anticipated inside weeks, Prime Minister Keir Starmer this week known as the present system “unsustainable, indefensible and unfair”.

The situations most definitely to lead to a refused declare had been these that could be managed extra efficiently by an grownup than a toddler, like diabetes or bronchial asthma, consultants stated.

However amongst these to have had claims rejected since PIP’s introduction in 2013 are 1000’s dwelling with life-changing situations together with most cancers, blindness, psychosis, deafness and epilepsy.

The 124,000 younger individuals affected since then embrace Holly Crouch, who stated the choice by the Division for Work and Pensions (DWP) had left her feeling “like a burden” when “nothing modified however my age”.

She stated she had been refused PIP when she utilized as an adolescent, regardless of offering proof from specialists saying she was liable to sudden, life-threatening epileptic seizures.

Miss Crouch stated the DWP had determined she not wanted help as a result of she had been seizure-free for a number of weeks.

Holly’s dad and mom subsequently misplaced their Carers’ Allowance funds however nonetheless have to offer fixed supervision.

The 21-year-old from East Sussex stated: “My situation has not magically disappeared and I am not faking this.

“Every little thing was taken so rapidly and I felt indignant, uncared for and like I hadn’t been believed. It was so arduous to take care of.”

Holly stated she had misplaced three jobs due to her epilepsy and needed to “depend on others for the whole lot” with out PIP.

“I will by no means really feel like an grownup as I am unable to do issues everybody else is ready to, like drive or work,” she stated. “My dad and mom even need to be there after I bathe or boil a kettle as I may have a seizure.

“I perceive there might be adjustments to situations, however that is what evaluations are for – you should not simply have your cash stopped at 16 when you find yourself not sufficiently old for the method.”

James Taylor, Scope’s government director of technique, stated the variety of younger individuals dropping out on monetary help was “worrying”.

He known as on the federal government to work with disabled individuals and “repair our damaged welfare system”.

Three-quarters of these deemed ineligible for PIP had failed the DWP’s points-based evaluation, in keeping with BBC evaluation.

Whereas appeals might be lodged and a few individuals do obtain larger awards below PIP than DLA, the BBC heard of younger individuals refused advantages regardless of the numerous influence of their disabilities on each day life.

They embrace:

• A number of who reportedly failed the evaluation as a result of they had been in a position to work part-time or attend faculty or faculty
• A young person with Down’s syndrome who advised his PIP assessor he may do the whole lot he was quizzed about, however didn’t clarify the intensive help he wanted to take action
• A young person with studying difficulties who stated he may cook dinner for himself however didn’t point out he had damaged a number of microwaves in attempting to take action

Considerations had been repeatedly raised about PIP assessors missing data of particular situations and selections being taken with out recourse to medical proof or contacting these concerned in a claimant’s care.

Incapacity and welfare rights organisations say the system leads to wrongful selections, with DWP outcomes ceaselessly overturned at tribunal.

The Royal Nationwide Institute for Blind Folks, Epilepsy Society, the Nationwide Autistic Society and Contact are amongst these calling for speedy reform.

• Private Independence Fee is a profit for over-16s with long-term bodily or psychological well being situations

• It isn’t means-tested and goals to fund the additional dwelling prices related to having a incapacity

• Assessments deal with how succesful somebody is of dwelling independently and use a collection of questions on each day actions

• Factors are awarded primarily based on the person’s skills and what assist they want

• These factors are added as much as decide whether or not the brink for a declare is met

• A 3rd social gathering – like a father or mother or carer – can apply to signify somebody with out the capability to take action themselves

A latest Decision Basis report discovered the variety of younger individuals in receipt of incapacity advantages falls considerably between the ages of 15 and 17.

The think-tank stated the failure to qualify – or apply for – PIP was leaving many “going through a monetary cliff-edge” as they approached maturity.

Fightback4Justice, which advocates for disabled individuals within the welfare system, has known as for the method to be extra transitional.

Its founder, Michelle Cardno, stated: “Younger individuals are being handled as adults from the day they attain 16, when most don’t perceive the system.”

Sally Donley acted for her son Euan Hawes when he was invited to transition from DLA to PIP.

She says she spent two hours speaking with an assessor concerning the influence of Euan’s disabilities, which embrace autism, obsessive compulsive dysfunction and sensory processing dysfunction.

“His evaluation was with a nurse who had no background in his points and he ended up solely scoring factors for not mixing with others,” stated Ms Donley, from Hampshire.

“As a result of I stated he may cook dinner eggs within the microwave, they stated he may cook dinner for himself they usually stated he goes to school independently – but it surely’s a specialist faculty he travels an hour in a taxi to.”

Euan’s declare was refused, however the determination was finally overturned and he was granted PIP’s highest charges when Ms Donley took the DWP to a tribunal.

“The stress this places on households is horrendous and merciless,” she stated. “You’ve gotten dad and mom attempting to care for youngsters with disabilities they usually’re having to take hours to assemble proof for courtroom appeals.

“They should pay attention they usually want to have a look at medical proof.”

The federal government is being known as upon to convey the remainder of the UK according to Scotland, the place the transition to grownup incapacity advantages can now happen at 18.

Ms Donley, who helps these calls, added: “Euan’s 18 now and I am nonetheless combating for him. I do know I will be combating for him till my final breath.”

A DWP spokesman stated: “Constructing on our Get Britain Working White Paper, we are going to convey ahead proposals for reforming the well being and incapacity advantages system inside weeks, in order that it gives youngsters, younger adults and their households with the help they want in a manner that is truthful on the taxpayer, and helps those that can work safe employment.”

Extra about this story

The Shared Knowledge Unit makes knowledge journalism accessible to information organisations throughout the media trade, as a part of a partnership between the BBC and the Information Media Affiliation.

Learn extra concerning the Native Information Partnerships right here.