‘Soiled’ for consuming fish: How row in Mumbai is newest conflict between vegetarians and non-vegetarians

An residence advanced in Mumbai’s Ghatkopar lately discovered itself on the centre of a heated dispute, not over noise or parking complaints, however over the meals decisions of its residents.

Marathi-speaking households residing within the society have been allegedly labelled “soiled” by some members of the Gujarati neighborhood for consuming non-vegetarian meals. The comment didn’t go down properly with the Marathi-speaking residents, resulting in a heated argument that escalated to the purpose the place police needed to step in to calm issues down.

A video of the confrontation shortly unfold throughout social media platforms, drawing widespread consideration and reigniting the long-standing debate between vegetarians and non-vegetarians in Mumbai, notably with regards to housing and public area.

Right here’s what we all know to date.

What occurred within the society?

The controversy started at Ghatkopar’s Sambhav Darshan Co-operative Housing Society, the place a resident claimed that his neighbour raised objections whereas he was having non-vegetarian meals.

Based on the resident, Ram Ringe, his neighbour had allegedly advised him, “You Marathi individuals are soiled, you eat fish and meat.”

Following the altercation over the selection of meals, Ringe reached out to the Maharashtra Navnirman Sena (MNS) to boost the difficulty and search assist.

Traditionally, each the Raj Thackeray-led MNS and the undivided Shiv Sena have argued that Marathi-speakers encountered hardships in shopping for or renting flats in sure areas as a result of their non-vegetarian meals habits.

MNS responds

On Wednesday evening, MNS leaders arrived on the society and instantly warned members of the Gujarati neighborhood. They made it clear that any mistreatment of Marathi residents would have penalties.

In a video from the altercation that has since gone viral, an MNS chief may be heard saying, “He thinks Marathis are soiled. Meaning Maharashtra can be soiled. So, why did he come to a grimy place?”

The chief additional warned the person that if he continued misbehaving, “he wouldn’t have the ability to step out of society.”

Tensions didn’t ease the subsequent day. On Thursday, MNS members visited the society once more after some residents reportedly demanded a boycott of Ram Ringe within the widespread WhatsApp group.

This time, the MNS confronted society chairman Raj Parte instantly and warned him that if the harassment continued, the social gathering would “reply in its personal model.”

“Anyone can dwell in Mumbai and work right here, however we won’t tolerate such issues… how can others dictate what they need to eat?” Parte stated.

Because the state of affairs escalated, police have been known as to the housing advanced. Nevertheless, no formal complaints have been filed by both social gathering.

A police officer advised NDTV, “Ringe contested the residence committee election and misplaced. Since then, two factions have emerged on the residence advanced. We are going to speak to each side and guarantee this inner matter is solved.”

Later, state minister Asish Shelar condemned such incidents of “disrespect” on the idea of language as unacceptable.

“Nobody ought to commit the sin of trying down upon Marathi-speaking folks, their language and their tradition,” Shelar stated.

“It’s the stand of the Maharashtra authorities that the Marathi language and its tradition must be revered. Creating disrespect amongst folks of various languages shouldn’t be acceptable to us,” he warned.

The rising veg vs non-veg divide in Mumbai

What occurred in Ghatkopar isn’t a one-off. Over time, Mumbai has witnessed a rising cultural divide the place dietary preferences, particularly between vegetarians and non-vegetarians, have develop into grounds for dispute in housing, commute, and even neighbourhood interactions.

Throughout a number of pockets of town, similar to Ghatkopar and Mahavir Nagar, it’s not unusual to seek out housing listings that include a “Vegetarians solely” disclaimer. These unofficial restrictions are sometimes handed off as way of life preferences of its residents, however for a lot of, they really feel like coded types of exclusion.

In a single telling incident reported by The Straits Occasions, residents from a largely vegetarian society in a western suburb of Mumbai claimed that rubbish collectors refused to choose up waste that included fish bones or egg shells. Meat-eating residents have been left with no selection however to seek out alternate methods of disposing of their kitchen waste.

For a lot of newcomers to town, this bias is encountered throughout house-hunting.

A Mumbai-based non-profit sector worker, who wished to stay nameless, shared how she needed to strike off seven shortlisted flats just because they have been out there just for vegetarians.

“It is a quite common downside in Mumbai when house-hunting. You’re aware of it and select to not interact with homeowners who put out their homes just for vegetarians,”  the 35-year-old lady advised the information outlet. She believes such exclusion stems from a perception system the place homeowners really feel their kitchens may be “contaminated” by elements they personally keep away from or take into account religiously inappropriate.

“I can not see motive in any type of discrimination,” she added.

Ultimately, she and her husband discovered a house owned by a Christian household in what she described as a “very combined” spiritual neighbourhood, one thing she felt was more and more uncommon in in the present day’s Mumbai.

Even town’s public transport system has had its share of food-related flare-ups. In 2016, a bunch of commuters on the Mumbai Metro was stopped for carrying fish contained in the practice. Whereas authorities defended the transfer, citing coverage guidelines, the incident shortly snowballed right into a political flashpoint.

MNS leaders questioned why Metro rules ought to differ from different types of public transport, like buses and locals, the place carrying uncooked meat isn’t prohibited, Mumbai Mirror had reported.

The rising frequency of such incidents factors to a rising, deeper cultural divide and is regarding for a metropolis identified for its range.

_With enter from businesses
_