The captaincy conundrum: who shall be Rohit’s successor?

Jasprit Bumrah was the final man to guide India to victory in a Take a look at match. Jasprit Bumrah was the final man to guide India in a Take a look at match, interval. And but…

And but, Jasprit Bumrah isn’t actually the front-runner to change into India’s subsequent Take a look at captain, a place that lies vacant following the retirement from the longest model 12 days again of Rohit Sharma.

Traditionally, India haven’t had too many long-term ‘bowling captains’ within the five-day sport. Bishan Singh Bedi, the magical left-arm spinner, led in 22 Exams between 1976 and 1978 (think about that, India taking part in these many Take a look at matches in that quick a span). Considered one of his companions in crime within the legendary spin quartet, S. Venkataraghavan, was the captain at two 60-over World Cups in England, in 1975 and 1979, although he helmed the Take a look at aspect in solely 5 of his 57 Take a look at appearances.

Kapil Dev, the all-rounder non-pareil, was entrusted with the management position over two stints between 1983 and 1987 and Anil Kumble, arguably India’s biggest match-winner, lastly obtained his due in 2007 when he succeeded his Karnataka teammate Rahul Dravid. However traditionally, India greater than most international locations haven’t been too form to bowler-captains.

If Bumrah doesn’t essentially fall in that bracket, it’s largely to do with one of many extra trendy phrases within the trendy cricketing lexicon, workload administration. In his, and India’s, final Take a look at on the Sydney Cricket Floor, the designated captain for the match after Rohit terribly sat himself out of the sport owing to type, Bumrah didn’t final the space, laid low by a decrease again damage that prevented him from bowling in Australia’s second innings with the Take a look at and the collection on the road. Recognized later as a ‘stress response’, that damage stored him out of motion for 3 months.

Bumrah has had points along with his again prior to now as properly, even needing corrective surgical procedure in April 2023. Given that he’s the unquestioned spearhead of the assault, irrespective of the place they play, India should deal with him with tact, care, warning and customary sense. Not wrap him in cotton wool, no, however be certain that he isn’t bowled to the bottom, that his physique is ‘managed’ to forestall to the extent potential one other flare-up of the again. Bumrah, him of the uniquely Bumrah motion, is 31. He is a great cricketer, a powerful and deeply invested pupil of the sport who will make – has already made – a terrific captain. However India want Bumrah the bowler greater than Bumrah the captain.

There isn’t a assure, regardless of the lengthy gaps between the primary and second Exams after which the third and fourth Exams in England this summer time, that the Gujarat pacer will play all 5 matches in India’s first Take a look at outing within the post-Rohit-Virat Kohli period.

If he stays match and will get via the collection with out lacking a single sport, improbable. But when he does want a break to recharge mentally and to recuperate bodily – which is a chance whose diploma of prevalence is dependent upon one’s perspective – then it’ll necessitate any person else stepping in briefly for a sport right here, a fixture there, not the perfect scenario because the nationwide workforce embarks on a section of rebuilding.

True, when the nominated captain is injured or banned (as they as soon as was, largely for overrate infractions), their deputy is compelled to step in, however these are circumstances past one’s management. In Bumrah’s case, it’s laborious to not entertain fears about his physique, to not imagine that he would possibly have to skip a Take a look at in the midst of a collection for apparent causes. That, the necessity for continuity and a settled, secure management determine, greater than the rest means the senior decision-making group inside Indian cricket – chief selector Ajit Agarkar and head coach Gautam Gambhir major amongst them – should flip to somebody aside from Bumrah, nonetheless a lot of a blow that could be to the latter’s aspirations and ambitions.

Who’s that ‘somebody aside from Bumrah?’ In varied quarters, it’s apparently a really easy selection – Shubman Gill, the Punjab batter who has run an excellent ship with Gujarat Titans on this 12 months’s IPL and who, by his personal admission, loves the accountability of the captaincy which, he says, retains him concerned within the sport always.

Earlier this 12 months, when the Board of Management for Cricket in India mandated that each one worldwide gamers should play home cricket round their nationwide duties every time potential, all of India’s big-ticket names turned up within the Ranji Trophy for his or her respective states. Rohit, on the time nonetheless the Take a look at captain, was comfortable to play beneath Ajinkya Rahane in Mumbai’s defeat to Jammu & Kashmir, whereas Kohli’s skipper for Delhi towards Railways was Ayush Badoni, who additionally led Rishabh Pant when the stumper turned out towards Saurashtra.

However not so Gill. As he returned to the Punjab set-up for his or her showdown towards Karnataka on the M. Chinnaswamy Stadium in Bengaluru in the direction of the tip of January, the 25-year-old wasn’t simply comfortable, but in addition keen, to take over the reins. “Being the captain retains you within the sport on a regular basis,” he reasoned on the finish of the match by which he adopted up 4 within the first innings with 102 within the second despite the fact that his workforce slumped to an innings loss. “As an individual, I prefer to be concerned within the sport and what’s occurring. It brings out one of the best in me as a participant when I’m consistently concerned within the sport.”

Gill didn’t have an awesome first season as skipper on the Titans final 12 months when he took over from Hardik Pandya, however this 12 months, he has are available in for particular reward for his operating of the ship, for his calmness and poise beneath strain, for his good decision-making and for his man-management and tactical nous.

In so some ways, captaining an IPL franchise is probably much more difficult than captaining a global outfit and Gill has had an inexpensive run as skipper. He was Rohit’s deputy on the Champions Trophy which India received in Dubai in March, he led the Indian workforce throughout a five-match Twenty20 Worldwide tour of Zimbabwe in July which the guests clinched 4-1. He has time on his aspect, he can develop into the position with the help of his head coach and different senior members within the aspect, there are such a lot of containers he ticks that it will likely be tempting to cease trying past him straightaway.

However as Mahendra Singh Dhoni so famously mentioned so a few years again, in India, each praise is adopted by a ‘however.’ In Gill’s case, the chorus have to be: ‘However his report outdoors the subcontinent is sort of abnormal, isn’t it?’

Abroad struggles

It’s too, one should admit. Gill’s Take a look at debut in Australia in 2020-21 was an unqualified success. As one among a number of inexperienced members of a workforce that stored dropping established names at an alarming regularity – one after the opposite, Virat Kohli, Mohammed Shami, Ravindra Jadeja, R. Ashwin, Hanuma Vihari and Bumrah had been dominated out at varied levels for one purpose or the opposite – Gill greater than held his personal, ending with 259 runs and a mean of 51.80 in his three appearances. Within the euphoria of Pant’s sensational unbeaten 89 that muscled India to the Gabba heist within the decider, Gill’s fluent 91 that kickstarted the profitable chase of 328 is essentially a footnote.

However since that tour, Gill has struggled for affect whereas taking part in away from Asia. After that 91 in January 2021, his highest rating in 18 innings in non-Asian international locations is 36. He voluntarily moved right down to No. 3 from his opening slot throughout the tour of the West Indies in July 2023, which is the place he has batted completely within the final 22 months. Now, in Rohit’s absence, does he transfer one place up and again to the highest of the order? Or, in Kohli’s retirement, does he transfer one place right down to No. 4, a place embellished within the final three a long time by Kohli and earlier than him the peerless Sachin Tendulkar? Will captaincy reignite his fondness for large runs outdoors Asia? Or will it weigh him down and can his frustrations mount within the occasion of runs persevering with to be laborious to come back by?

And so, if not Gill, then who? Perhaps somebody who has led the nation beforehand, and in all three codecs at that? Perhaps the senior most specialist batter within the aspect? Perhaps the one who made his Take a look at debut in December 2014, scored a century in his subsequent Take a look at per week later and had a global ton in every of the three codecs in somewhat over 18 months after first representing the nation?

Rahul.
| Picture Credit score:
FILE PHOTO: Getty Pictures

Why not Ok.L. Rahul? Rahul has performed 58 Exams, however like Gill (35.05 in 32 Exams), he additionally has a middling common – 33.57 which, by all accounts is an effective 12-15 runs per innings lower than the place it ought to be. There’s one faculty of thought that believes he’s batting at his finest now, freely and with out psychological shackles, and that he ought to be left to do exactly that. Then, there’s the opposite which insists that the state of his thoughts that has sparked a batting revolution of types is exactly what is looking out for the Take a look at captaincy to be conferred on him. Rahul is just 33, and might maybe assist Gill and Pant via a interval of apprenticeship after which, perhaps two years on, the reins can change fingers.

India have alternated between stable succession plans – Dravid after Sourav Ganguly, Dhoni after Kumble and Kohli after Dhoni – and the odd left-field punt, resembling Ganguly succeeding Tendulkar when the latter stop in early 2000. As they put together for all times after (Take a look at captain) Rohit, a tough highway – of transition and to redemption — lies forward. Will Gill match the invoice?’